Table 6: Neurological effects of orally administered aluminum salts on rats, mice and monkeys
Study |
Species |
Exposure |
Exposure
duration |
Results |
Hermenegildo et
al.,
1999 |
rat |
2.5% Al sulfate in drinking water (0.2% Al) |
3-5 weeks |
- altered cerebellar glutamate-nitric oxide-cGMP pathway:
- decreased N-methyl-D-aspartate-induced extracellular cGMP increase
- increased s-nitroso-N-acetyl penicillamine-induced extracellular cGMP increase
- reduced cerebellar calmodulin and nitric oxide synthase levels
- reduced basal activity of guanylate cyclase
- decreased basal extracellular cGMP levels
|
Kumar, 1998 |
rat |
gavage: 320 mg Al/kg-bw per day (as AlCl3) |
4 and 14 days
or 60 days |
- increased acetylcholinesterase activity in olfactory bulb, striatum and
hypothalamus (4 and 14 days)
- decreased acetylcholinesterase activity (60 days)
|
Abd El-Fattah et
al.,
1998 |
mouse |
purified diet + 2000, 4000 or 6000 µg
Al/g diet (as Al acetate)
purified diet + 2000 or 4000 µg Al/g diet (as Al acetate) |
2 weeks
8 weeks |
- decreased glutathione levels in brain (2 weeks - high exposure, 8 weeks -
high exposure)
- thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARs) increased (lipid peroxidation)
(8 weeks - both exposures)
- effects ameliorated by co-administration of vitamin E
|
Zheng and Liang, 1998 |
rat |
1600 mg Al/L in drinking water (as AlCl3) |
90 days |
- impaired step-down test performance (passive avoidance)
- impaired Morris water maze performance
- no effect on acetylcholinesterase activity
|
Varner et
al., 1998 |
rat |
0.5 ppm AlF3 in drinking water |
52 weeks |
- damaged and abnormal neurons and decreased neuronal density in
hippocampus and neocortex
|
Katyal et
al., 1997 |
rat |
standard diet + 250 mg
AlCl3·6H2O/kg-bw per day |
6 weeks |
- decreased thiol levels in brain
- decreased brain glutathione reductase and ATPase activities
- no significant effect on TBARs or glutathione-S-transferase
|
Somova et
al., 1997 |
rat |
5 or 20 mg AlCl3/kg-bw per day in drinking water |
6 months |
- temporal cortex - reduced cell density in ganglionic layer and spongiform
changes (high exposure)
- hippocampus - neurofilaments, deformity and vacuolization of nuclei (high
exposure)
|
Sánchez et
al., 1997 |
rat |
50 or 100 mg Al/kg-bw per day (as Al(NO3)3·9H2O in drinking water) + 355 and 710 mg citrate/kg-bw per day, respectively |
6.5 months |
- decreased calcium concentrations in brains of old rats (16 months) (high exposure)
- decreased manganese concentrations in brains of your (21 days) and adult (8 months) rats (high exposure)
- decreased copper and zinc concentrations in brains of young (21 days) rats
(high and low exposure)
- decreased iron concentrations in brains of young (21 days) rats (high
exposure)
- no effect on brain magnesium concentrations
|
Sarin et
al., 1998 |
monkey |
gavage: 25 mg Al/kg-bw every second day (as Al lactate) |
52 weeks |
- decreased total lipid, glycolipid and phospholipid content of brain
- increased cholesterol levels and phospholipid to cholesterol ratio in brain
- increased lipid peroxidation (hippocampus > cerebral cortex > corpus striatum) and decreased ganglioside levels
- decreased Na+K+-ATPase, acetylcholinesterase and 2',3'-cyclic nucleotide
phosphohydrolase activities in brain
|
Domingo et
al., 1996 |
rat |
50 or 100 mg Al/kg-bw per day (as Al(NO3)3·9H2O in drinking water) + 355 and 710 mg citrate/kg-bw per day, respectively |
6.5 months |
- no effects on open field activity
- no effects on shuttle box performance (passive avoidance)
|
Gupta and Shukla, 1995 |
rat |
500 mg Al/L in drinking water (as AlCl3) |
12 months |
- increased lipid peroxidation in brain (hippocampus and whole brain)
- decreased activities of superoxide dismutase, glutathione peroxidase and
catalase
|
Sahin et
al., 1995 |
mouse |
drinking water + 4.4 µg Al/L (as AlCl3) |
90 days |
- decreased motor coordination (rota-rod)
|
Florence et
al., 1994 |
rat |
standard diet + 1 g Al/kg diet (as Al citrate) |
6 months |
- vacuolated astrocytes (cell body and processes)
- swollen astrocytic processes
- vacuolization of neuronal cytoplasm
- neuronal nuclear membrane indentations, vacuoles and inclusions
|
Varner et
al., 1994 |
rat |
0.5, 5 or 50 ppm AlF3 in drinking water |
45 weeks |
- no effects on open field analysis and walking patterns (locomotor activity)
- no effects on balance beam test (motor coordination)
- no effects on T-maze performance (spontaneous alternation)
- no effects on water maze performance
- altered olfactory performance (medium and high exposure)
|
Oteiza et
al., 1993 |
mouse |
purified diet + 1000 µg Al/g diet (as AlCl3)
+ 3.5% citrate |
5-7 weeks |
- decreased forelimb and hindlimb grip strength
- increased air puff startle response
- no effect on thermal sensitivity, negative geotaxis and auditory startle
- no change in brain TBARs or glutamine synthetase and alkaline phosphatase
activities
|
Bilkei-Gorzó, 1993 |
rat |
gavage: 30 or 100 mg AlCl3/kg-bw per day, 300 mg Al(OH)3/kg-bw per day or 100 mg Al(OH)3/kg-bw per day + 30mg citrate/kg-bw per day |
90 days |
- impaired maze performance (all exposures)
- increased brain acetylcholinesterase activity (high exposure AlCl3 and low
exposure Al(OH)3)
- decreased choline acetyltransferase activity (low exposure AlCl3)
|
Lal et
al., 1993 |
rat |
500 mg Al/L in drinking water (as AlCl3) (12 mg Al/day per rat) |
180 days |
- reduced spontaneous locomotor activity
- impaired acquisition, extinction and reacquisition of an active avoidance task
shuttle box)
- impaired maze relearning ability
- increased brain lipid peroxidation
- reduced brain Mg2+- and Na+K+-ATPase acitivities
|
Varner et
al., 1993 |
rat |
0.5, 5 or 50 ppm AlF3 in drinking water |
45 weeks |
- reduced numbers of neurons in hippocampus (all exposures)
- neurons in hippocampus disorganized (all exposures)
|
Johnson et
al., 1992 |
rat |
adults: 0.3% Al2(SO4)3·18H2O in
drinking water
weanlings: 0.1-0.3% Al2(SO4)3·18H2O
in drinking water |
3 months
8 weeks |
- adults: decreased levels of microtubule associated protein-2 (MAP-2)
(hippocampus and brain stem) and spectrin (hippocampus)
- weanlings: decreased MAP-2 levels in cortex and brainstem, increased cAMP
levels and decreased inositol triphosphate levels in hippocampus
|
Golub et
al., 1992a |
mouse |
semi-purified diet + 1000 µg Al/g diet (as Al lactate) |
90 days |
- decreased motor activity, hindlimb grip strength and auditory and air puff
startle responsiveness
- no effects on temperature sensitivity or foot splay
- no effect on lipid peroxidation (TBARs)
|
Roy et
al., 1991 |
mouse |
gavage: 17-172 mg Al/kg-bw per day (as Al2(SO4)3·18H2O or KAl(SO4)2·12H2O) |
21 days |
- multifocal, dose- and duration-dependent degeneration of nerve cells in
cerebral cortex, subcortical region and base of brain (≥2.86 mg Al/kg-bw per
day as Al2(SO4)3·18H2O or ≥4.86 mg Al/kg-bw per day as KAl(SO4)2·12H2O)
|
Flora et
al., 1991 |
rat |
gavage: 25 mg Al/kg-bw per day (asAl(NO3)3) |
6 weeks |
- brain dopamine and 5-hydroxytryptamine levels decreased, norepinephrine
levels increased
|
Fraga et
al., 1990 |
mouse |
purified diet + 500 or 1000 µg Al/g diet (as Al lactate) |
10 weeks |
- increased lipid peroxidation in brain (TBARs production) (high exposure)
|
Golub et
al., 1989 |
rat |
purified diet + 500 or 1000 µg Al/g diet (as Al lactate) (62 or 130 mg Al/kg-bw per day) |
6 weeks |
- decreased motor activity (high exposure)
|
Connor et
al., 1989 |
rat |
3.7% Al2(SO4)3·18H2O in drinking water (0.3% Al; 2.0 mmol Al/day per
rat) |
30 days |
- decreased retention of passive avoidance response
- no effect on open field activity
|
Connor et
al., 1988 |
rat |
3.7% Al2(SO4)3·18H2O in drinking water (0.3% Al; 2.0 mmol Al/day per
rat) |
30 days |
- impaired acquisition and retention of a passive avoidance learned response
- no effect on active avoidance response, radial arm maze or open field activity
- increased hippocampal muscarinic receptors
- no effect on choline acetyltransferase activity
|
Johnson and Jope, 1987 |
rat |
0.3% Al in drinking water (2.4% Al citrate [5.6 mmol Al/day per rat] or 3.7% Al2(SO4)3·18H2O [1.8 mmol Al/day per rat]) |
4 weeks |
- increased cAMP levels in cerebellum, cortex, hippocampus and striatum
- increased cGMP levels in cerebellum and striatum (Al sulfate) and
hippocampus (Al sulfate + citrate)
- choline levels decreased in cortex, hippocampus and striatum (Al citrate)
|
Fleming and Joshi, 1987 |
rat |
100 µM AlCl3 in drinking water |
1 year |
- impaired T-maze performance
|
Thorne et
al., 1987 |
rat - weanling |
2400 mg Al(OH)3/kg-bw per day in drinking water |
60 days |
- no effect on open field activity (horizontal or vertical movement)
- no effect on passive avoidance test
- no effect on radial maze performance
- some correlations between activity and brain aluminum levels
|
Thorne et
al., 1986 |
rat - adult |
1513, 2697 or 3617 mg Al/kg-bw per day (as Al(OH)3 in diet) |
30 days |
- no effect on open field activity (horizontal or vertical movement)
- no effect on passive avoidance test
- no effect on visual discrimination performance
- some correlations between test performance and brain aluminum levels
|
Commissaris et
al., 1982 |
rat |
standard diet + 0.2% Al (as AlCl3) |
12 weeks or 11months |
- no effects on motor coordination (rota-rod) (12 weeks)
- reduced motor activity (both exposure durations)
- slowed acquisition of passive avoidance behaviour (shuttle box) (11 months)
- impaired retention of passive avoidance behaviour (12 weeks)
|
Bowdler et
al., 1979 |
rat |
gavage: 200, 400 or 600 mg AlCl3·6H2O/kg-bw per day or 195 mg Al(OH)3/kg-bw per day |
28 days |
- increased general activity (open field maze)
- decreased motor coordination (rota-rod)
- increased sensitivity to flicker
- no effect on shuttle box performance (passive avoidance)
|
Krasovskii et
al., 1979 |
rat |
gavage: 0.0025, 0.25 or 2.5 mg Al/kgbw per day |
6-12 months |
- slowdown in development and reinforcement of conditioned reflexes
- high value of index of latent stage of conditioned reflexes
- altered small movements
|